summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/plans/ImplementationPlan.md
AgeCommit message (Collapse)Author
2026-08-11feat: P1 tool improvements and P5 Agent Skills standard compliancetanaka takashi
P1: Tool小改善 1. tailバイナリ判定 (TextFileDetector): - file_search tailモードでtext/binary判定を追加 - 先頭4KBのみ読み、BOM確認(UTF-8/UTF-16 LE/BE)→UTF-8 strict byte検証 - NULバイトのみ判定不可(UTF-16でNULが正常出現するため) - binaryファイルはToolValidationExceptionで拒否 - TextFileDetectorクラスへ判定ロジックを分離 2. file_edit rename機能: - file_edit.operation=renameを追加(新規toolではない) - new_path property追加、Write capability要求(source/destination双方) - destination既存時は禁止(overwrite不可) - cross-volume renameは不支持、Tool failureとして拒否 - FileRenameTransaction + RecoveryManager file.rename recovery追加 - crash recovery: destination hash == journal記録の場合のみ戻す P5: Agent Skills open standard準拠 3. Skill形式をagentskills.io標準へ移行: - legacy単一Markdown形式(skills/*.md)を廃止 - <skill-name>/SKILL.md標準directory形式のみ対応 - YAML frontmatter必須(name/description)、YamlDotNetで解析 - validation: name必須(1-64文字,lowercase英数字+hyphen,親dir名一致), description必須(1-1024文字), malformed YAML reject, duplicate fatal 4. Progressive Disclosure: - Stage 1 Discovery: name+descriptionのみをsystem messageへ(name+desc一覧) - Stage 3 Instructions: 選択Skillの本文のみ注入 - PromptComposer: 全文埋め込みを廃止、カタログ形式へ変更 - PromptContext: Skills→AvailableSkills+SelectedSkillsへ分割 - 未選択Skill本文はpromptへ入らない 5. Internal Tool境界維持: - skill_read等のInternal Tool追加なし - Internal Toolは6群(file_search/file_read/file_edit/process_run/task_update/dir)のまま - Skill選択・本文ロードはAgent Runtime/Prompt Context Managementの責務 6. AgentSkill data model (Agent.Core/Skills/AgentSkill.cs): - RootPath, Name, Description, Instructions, License?, Compatibility?, Metadata?, AllowedTools? - SkillLoader(Agent.App)がYamlDotNetでfrontmatter解析→AgentSkill構築 設計判断: - renameはfile_edit operation拡張(新規toolではない) - rmdir空dirのみ制約は維持 - Skill load != permission grant維持 - allowed-toolsはSandbox permissionとして解釈しない - YamlDotNetはAgent.App側のみ使用(Agent.Coreへ依存追加なし) 変更対象: - TextFileDetector.cs: 新規、text/binary判定 - WindowsToolBackend.cs: tail binary判定統合、rename case追加 - InternalToolCatalog.cs: file_edit operation enum に rename 追加、new_path property - InternalToolValidator.cs: rename時new_path必須検証 - TransactionalFileEditor.cs: Rename() + FileRenameTransaction - RecoveryManager.cs: file.rename recovery - AgentSkill.cs: 新規data model - SkillLoader.cs: 全面書き換え、YamlDotNet frontmatter解析、validation - PromptComposer.cs: Progressive Disclosure、AvailableSkills+SelectedSkills - AgentRuntimeSettings.cs: Skills型変更 - AgentRuntime.cs: SelectedSkills=[]で初期化 - Program.cs: SkillLoader戻り値型対応 - Specifications.md: FS-07 rename、Skill節Agent Skills standard準拠 - Design.md: §7.1 tail binary判定、§7.3 rename、AgentSkill model - ImplementationPlan.md: Prompt順序更新、Skill標準準拠 テスト: - SecurityPolicyTests.cs: tail binary拒否/UTF-8/UTF-16 text許可、rename正常/dest既存拒否/許可外拒否 - InternalToolTests.cs: rename validationテスト追加 - ConfigurationTests.cs: SkillLoader標準形式/missing frontmatter/name mismatch/duplicate tests - PromptAndRuntimeTests.cs: PromptContext型変更対応、skill catalog検証 検証結果: - Release build: 警告0、エラー0 - Core tests: 61/61 PASS、skip 0 - Planner tests: 10/10 PASS、skip 0 - Internal Tool 6群固定: 確認済み
2026-08-10perf(sandbox): apply ACLs at approved rootstanaka takashi
Replace per-descendant ACL enumeration, security descriptor snapshots, journal entries, audit events, and cleanup rewrites with one inheritable ACE and one snapshot per approved directory root. Exact file approvals continue to receive non-inheritable file ACEs, and nested roots retain independent least-privilege scopes cleaned in reverse order. Keep protected descendant DACLs protected instead of disabling inheritance protection. Such paths remain OS-denied, preserving fail-safe behavior without silently expanding the SandboxPolicy. Remove the obsolete descendant normalization pass. Restoring the root security descriptor removes inherited Application SID ACEs from existing and Task-created descendants; crash recovery performs the same root descriptor restoration from the journal. Add tests for existing-child inheritance, newly-created-child inheritance, protected descendants, one journal entry per root, exact descriptor restoration, no residual Application SID ACE, and independent-process crash recovery. Extend the existing elevated recovery and backend tests to validate inherited child cleanup and one ACL apply/restore event per root. Verification: Release build passed with 0 warnings and 0 errors; Core 50/50 passed; Planner 10/10 passed; focused ACL/recovery 3/3 passed; elevated Windows Security 28/28 passed; all reported skip 0. Operational evidence: the updated Release Bundle completed MCP Task 9b4a59a9-1f9b-4362-85f4-7b858899b488. ACL apply/restore decreased from 3,583/3,583 events taking 72/57 seconds to 3/3 root_inheritance events completing within the same second. WFP residual filters were 0 and the Task journal was removed. Release: refreshed the win-x64 self-contained folder bundle, clean ZIP, manifest, and checksum while preserving the local agent.yaml. Agent.Windows.dll SHA-256 is 24FDDD5727D5455170B6742B1D21E023A0BD70F92C225A2681BB5832C7AC0824; ZIP SHA-256 is EF7684C1A5A6155B774F4DF23CB08E9D1CF676351BF2B7D0F57915304495F456. No dependencies were added.
2026-08-10fix(agent): fail fast on sandbox policy denialtanaka takashi
Treat Policy Engine denials and UnauthorizedAccessException results as terminal tool failures by adding RetryAllowed metadata to ToolExecutionResult. Stop the Agent loop immediately after recording the denied tool result, transition the Task to failed, and run normal Task resource cleanup instead of returning the same failure to the LLM for another iteration. Correctable validation and process failures retain the existing bounded retry behavior. Expose RetryAllowed in llm.jsonl and document the fail-fast security invariant in Specifications, Design, and ImplementationPlan. Tests: Agent.Core.Tests 50/50 passed with skip 0; Release build passed with 0 warnings and 0 errors. The full Windows suite remained environment-blocked outside an elevated token: 14 tests failed while creating/deriving the fixed AppContainer or creating symlinks; 11 passed and none were skipped. Release: refreshed the win-x64 self-contained folder binaries, publish manifest, ZIP, and checksum while preserving the local agent.yaml. The clean ZIP contains no runtime logs or Task state.
2026-08-09feat(mcp): migrate server to MCP 2026-07-28tanaka takashi
Replace the MCP 1.4.1 stateful HTTP design with the official C# SDK 2.0.0 stateless transport. The SDK now owns protocol negotiation, server/discover, standard MCP headers, GET and DELETE handling, error serialization, caching hints, and legacy initialize compatibility; production code no longer maintains a custom wire-protocol workaround for MCP Inspector. Separate transport state from application conversation state. HTTP does not issue Mcp-Session-Id, while the existing session_id remains an Agent conversation identifier. Preserve agent_run and agent_status for clients without Tasks support and add the official ModelContextProtocol.Extensions.Tasks 2.0.0 path for capable clients. Add persistent MCP Task storage with atomic JSON replacement, user-only state location, configurable TTL and poll interval, restart recovery, cancellation correlation, and public Agent-to-MCP state mapping. Keep conformance-only tools and protocol exception fixtures in a test host so they cannot enter the Release Bundle. Run administrator, BFE, WFP transaction, and filter add/delete preflight before binding. Fail fast with exit code 2 and actionable localized diagnostics when sandbox enforcement is unavailable. Emit ready only after the listener starts and keep stdio stdout protocol-pure. Add shared rotating application and HTTP request logs. Record real socket endpoints, connection and trace identifiers, method, path, result, timing, media metadata, User-Agent, and MCP metadata. Do not trust X-Forwarded-For and do not log authorization, cookies, query data, request or response bodies, prompts, images, or Base64 payloads. Add typed logging and Tasks configuration, Japanese and English messages, protocol and operations documentation, design/specification deltas, traceability, and exact conformance acquisition/offline runner scripts for @modelcontextprotocol/conformance 0.2.0-alpha.11. Node remains test-only and is not a runtime dependency. Conformance evidence: server-stateless passed 28 of 28 checks with zero unexpected failures; DNS rebinding and multiple POST stream scenarios passed. The alpha Tasks lifecycle/cancel/error/required-task checks passed, while its wire-schema validator misclassifies CreateTaskResult and its MRTR composition remains incompatible with SDK 2.0.0. The aggregate conformance Gate is therefore recorded as PARTIAL, not PASS. Test-host fixture gaps for tools-list descriptions, JSON Schema diagnostics, caching fixtures, and a header-validation/required-Task capability conflict are also recorded without expected-failure masking. Verification: Release build passed with 0 warnings and 0 errors; Planner tests 10/10 and Core tests 47/47 passed with skip 0. The last Windows suite run passed 19/25; five WFP cases require an elevated token and one symlink case requires unavailable host privilege, so the elevated security Gate remains open. A win-x64 self-contained 1.0.0 Bundle and ZIP were regenerated under build/Release/publish; runtime check was intentionally skipped in this non-elevated session. Evidence remains under ignored artifacts/evidence/mcp-2026-07-28. Harden release regeneration when another shell holds the previous Bundle directory as its current directory: validate the target and remove only its children instead of deleting the directory itself. build/ and artifacts/ remain excluded from Git.
2026-08-09feat: AI Agent Sandbox MCP Server v1を実装tanaka takashi
Specifications、Design、ImplementationPlanの優先順位を整理し、単一Task実行モデル、typed option優先、設定可能なresource上限、local Ollamaを必須とするRelease Gateを文書化。 .NET 10/C# 14の5 production project、3 test project、E2E Clientを構築。typed YAML、en/ja locale、fixed/user prompt、stdioおよびloopback限定Streamable HTTP、agent_run/agent_status、Session、Ollama text/tool/Vision、TaskGraphとtoken accountingを実装。 Windows sandboxとしてfixed AppContainer、canonical/reparse検査、能力別ACL、path+SHA-256 executable approval、child-process restriction、Job Object、task journal、atomic file transaction、crash recoveryを実装。WFPのIPv4/IPv6 default denyとexact allow、dynamic session、temporary loopback exemption、管理者/BFE診断を追加。 Security/Recovery test、MCP/Ollama integration test、stdio/HTTP Operational E2E、Release Bundle生成・checksum・manifest・fresh extraction検査を追加。Requirement TraceabilityとPhase 0〜11の進捗、初回セットアップ可能なREADMEを整備。 Debug/Release/publish/objをrepository rootのbuild/へ集約し、旧project-local bin/objへの依存を除去。artifacts/とbuild/をGit管理外に設定し、clean checkoutでもsolution buildからE2E Clientまで生成可能にした。
2026-08-09First commit.tanaka takashi